DISQUS

Andy Beard - Internet Business Systems Discussion: 7 StumbleUpon Problems I Would Love To See Fixed

  • Tim Nash · 1 year ago
    My biggest request to StumbleUpon is stability, a Good example I was planning on doing a post on pimping your profile but in the space of the week StumbleUpon had changed how it handled images in profiles from none, to jpeg only, then PNG and then back to none it what appeared to be a few hours.

    I can see progress is important but I would like to see them rather then push new features fix the ones they have web2.0 seems to be a new term for buggy code.

    That said I still love and use StumbleUpon with all quirks!
  • Tim Nash · 1 year ago
    My biggest request to StumbleUpon is stability, a Good example I was planning on doing a post on pimping your profile but in the space of the week StumbleUpon had changed how it handled images in profiles from none, to jpeg only, then PNG and then back to none it what appeared to be a few hours.

    I can see progress is important but I would like to see them rather then push new features fix the ones they have web2.0 seems to be a new term for buggy code.

    That said I still love and use StumbleUpon with all quirks!
  • Dr. Pete · 1 year ago
    Funny, I was just noticing that you're almost always on my "Meet people like you" list on SU, Andy. Funnier still is that you were 1st on the list this afternoon, and Tim was 2nd (and he's the first commenter on this post). I have a feeling it just can't tell us 30-something white guys who read SEO articles apart ;)

    I have to admit that I find the SU taxonomy really unwieldy. I never understand what populates the default tags (which sometimes make no sense) and the fill-in-the-blank approach leaves me wondering what tags I should use. I end up putting "internet" on just about everything.
  • Dr. Pete · 1 year ago
    Funny, I was just noticing that you're almost always on my "Meet people like you" list on SU, Andy. Funnier still is that you were 1st on the list this afternoon, and Tim was 2nd (and he's the first commenter on this post). I have a feeling it just can't tell us 30-something white guys who read SEO articles apart ;)

    I have to admit that I find the SU taxonomy really unwieldy. I never understand what populates the default tags (which sometimes make no sense) and the fill-in-the-blank approach leaves me wondering what tags I should use. I end up putting "internet" on just about everything.
  • Eric Berlin · 1 year ago
    I simply find StumbleUpon frustrating to use and comprehend in general. I'd love to make use of it as a way to submit content to a social media site, help it to find an audience, and participate to some extent in that community (I'm not necessarily interested in stumbling upon new websites myself) but I'm not ashamed to say that I have trouble getting on board with how the thing works.

    Anyone else in this boat? I hear that people love it, that publishers love it, etc. but I've given it several chances and ending up simply walking away in frustration.

    For example, can you submit multiple articles from a single site, or do you submit one URL and then let the mystical forces of StumbleUpon take over? What do you once you've submitted a site or an article?

    Maybe I'm missing the magic Easy button that everyone else has managed to find ;-)
  • Eric Berlin · 1 year ago
    I simply find StumbleUpon frustrating to use and comprehend in general. I'd love to make use of it as a way to submit content to a social media site, help it to find an audience, and participate to some extent in that community (I'm not necessarily interested in stumbling upon new websites myself) but I'm not ashamed to say that I have trouble getting on board with how the thing works.

    Anyone else in this boat? I hear that people love it, that publishers love it, etc. but I've given it several chances and ending up simply walking away in frustration.

    For example, can you submit multiple articles from a single site, or do you submit one URL and then let the mystical forces of StumbleUpon take over? What do you once you've submitted a site or an article?

    Maybe I'm missing the magic Easy button that everyone else has managed to find ;-)
  • Steven Snell · 1 year ago
    #3 is a big one for me. I've always felt like there had to be some way of doing it, I was just too stupid to figure it out.
  • Steven Snell · 1 year ago
    #3 is a big one for me. I've always felt like there had to be some way of doing it, I was just too stupid to figure it out.
  • Jeff Quipp · 1 year ago
    Great post Andy ... agree completely. I also agree with Dr. Pete that the toxonomy is very unwieldy.
  • Jeff Quipp · 1 year ago
    Great post Andy ... agree completely. I also agree with Dr. Pete that the toxonomy is very unwieldy.
  • Jani Mikkonen · 1 year ago
    I'd be glad if a single page would only appear once. Sometimes, even in one session, same page can appear twice...
  • Jani Mikkonen · 1 year ago
    I'd be glad if a single page would only appear once. Sometimes, even in one session, same page can appear twice...
  • Sergey Rusak · 1 year ago
    I don't really like StumbleUpon because their traffic is random and visitors never buy anything. Once I got over 20 000 people from StumbleUpon in 1 day and 0 sales. Even Google Adsense did not bring me much after this "success".
  • Sergey Rusak · 1 year ago
    I don't really like StumbleUpon because their traffic is random and visitors never buy anything. Once I got over 20 000 people from StumbleUpon in 1 day and 0 sales. Even Google Adsense did not bring me much after this "success".
  • martial artist · 1 year ago
    Great info I never knew this stuff about stumbled upon. Really opened my eyes to some of the issues I never even thought about. I would love to see some better browser integration with stumbled upon too.
  • martial artist · 1 year ago
    Great info I never knew this stuff about stumbled upon. Really opened my eyes to some of the issues I never even thought about. I would love to see some better browser integration with stumbled upon too.
  • Tom Whittaker · 1 year ago
    This is a great post. I personally love the random nature of the site more than everything else.
  • Tom Whittaker · 1 year ago
    This is a great post. I personally love the random nature of the site more than everything else.
  • Kristie McNealy · 1 year ago
    I have to agree with Eric. For some reason StumbleUpon and I just don't click. If there's an Easy button, could someone please point me to it? ;)

    I had a huge jump (for me) in traffic because someone stumbled one of my posts the other day, and no matter what I did, I couldn't figure out who had stumbled it. It seems like that should be something I should be able to figure out, but as hard as I tried, I couldn't even find the stupid article on StumbleUpon at all...

    -Kristie
  • Kristie McNealy · 1 year ago
    I have to agree with Eric. For some reason StumbleUpon and I just don't click. If there's an Easy button, could someone please point me to it? ;)

    I had a huge jump (for me) in traffic because someone stumbled one of my posts the other day, and no matter what I did, I couldn't figure out who had stumbled it. It seems like that should be something I should be able to figure out, but as hard as I tried, I couldn't even find the stupid article on StumbleUpon at all...

    -Kristie
  • ny seo · 1 year ago
    i believe i noticed the sad day they added nofollows to links on users profile pages.

    overall though its still one of my all time favorites
  • ny seo · 1 year ago
    i believe i noticed the sad day they added nofollows to links on users profile pages.

    overall though its still one of my all time favorites
  • Webhosting Reality · 1 year ago
    I like Stumble as much as I like Digg because of its simple procedure in submitting a site. My only concern is that more often than not, I get lost what to do next after I stumble a site. They should improve that as well.
  • Webhosting Reality · 1 year ago
    I like Stumble as much as I like Digg because of its simple procedure in submitting a site. My only concern is that more often than not, I get lost what to do next after I stumble a site. They should improve that as well.
  • Stephen Cronin · 1 year ago
    I think StumbleUpon are missing out with #3. I'd love to catch everything my friends stumble - but it's not practical because of the 10 entry limit.

    Personally, I'd love them to dynamically create a feed for my what's new page so I could subscribe to it.
  • Stephen Cronin · 1 year ago
    I think StumbleUpon are missing out with #3. I'd love to catch everything my friends stumble - but it's not practical because of the 10 entry limit.

    Personally, I'd love them to dynamically create a feed for my what's new page so I could subscribe to it.
  • Internet Marketing Joy · 1 year ago
    I also feels the same. I also would like SU to improve on these areas so it will be more efficient and easy ti use.
  • Internet Marketing Joy · 1 year ago
    I also feels the same. I also would like SU to improve on these areas so it will be more efficient and easy ti use.
  • robdogg · 1 year ago
    1. I would like to see a next page when you search for something

    2. I would like to see who thumbed beyond just the 35

    3. i would like to see my friends fans

    4. i would like to block users from even viewing my profile or my stumbles.

    5. i would like to be able to RSS just my friends discoveries

    6. I would like to be able to syndicate all my friends discoveries into 1 feed like digg

    7. i would like more stumbling options such as stumble by date, mutual friends only, fans of only and and fans of mine, stumble recent discoveries, end etc...

    8. i would like an easier way to stick my top posts

    9. i would like a mass send to button

    10. I would like a mass message sent to ever SU member that SEO does not equal SPAM. I am really tired of these trolls repeatedly SPAMMING our discoveries with "crappy spam from crappy spammer".
  • robdogg · 1 year ago
    1. I would like to see a next page when you search for something

    2. I would like to see who thumbed beyond just the 35

    3. i would like to see my friends fans

    4. i would like to block users from even viewing my profile or my stumbles.

    5. i would like to be able to RSS just my friends discoveries

    6. I would like to be able to syndicate all my friends discoveries into 1 feed like digg

    7. i would like more stumbling options such as stumble by date, mutual friends only, fans of only and and fans of mine, stumble recent discoveries, end etc...

    8. i would like an easier way to stick my top posts

    9. i would like a mass send to button

    10. I would like a mass message sent to ever SU member that SEO does not equal SPAM. I am really tired of these trolls repeatedly SPAMMING our discoveries with "crappy spam from crappy spammer".
  • StumbleUpon, never leave home · 1 year ago
    Excellent post about StumbleUpon. Gave me the motivation I needed to create a SU related post of my own.
  • StumbleUpon, never leave home · 1 year ago
    Excellent post about StumbleUpon. Gave me the motivation I needed to create a SU related post of my own.
  • Mike - Twenty Steps · 1 year ago
    Without doubt the two things I would like to see StumbleUpon improve on are

    1) The ability to search my own Stumbles by tagging and context. The old interface was actually easier to do this.
    2) Your point #3. This frustrates the Hell out of me.

    Hopefully the good people at SU are aware of this and doing something about it.
  • Mike - Twenty Steps · 1 year ago
    Without doubt the two things I would like to see StumbleUpon improve on are

    1) The ability to search my own Stumbles by tagging and context. The old interface was actually easier to do this.
    2) Your point #3. This frustrates the Hell out of me.

    Hopefully the good people at SU are aware of this and doing something about it.
  • Clara · 1 year ago
    . . . when I look at my inbox, I really wish I could also see my replies on the same page.

    I feel you on this one. Several months ago I sent a friend a link to a great post about getting .edu and .gov backlinks and I lost it. Wouldn't it be nice I could see what I sent her.
  • Clara · 1 year ago
    . . . when I look at my inbox, I really wish I could also see my replies on the same page.

    I feel you on this one. Several months ago I sent a friend a link to a great post about getting .edu and .gov backlinks and I lost it. Wouldn't it be nice I could see what I sent her.
  • inspirationbit · 1 year ago
    I think this is the first time I come across someone finding holes in StumbleUpon. I'm having a big issue with StumbleUpon, that I don't know how to resolve and what causes it:
    whenever I Stumble a new page, it shows that "someone discovered" it, not me, not my nick. Does anyone know why is that?

    Also, Andy, there's a Social Media Mega Project going on that accepts submissions about 19 different social media sites (hosted by 10 different bloggers, who host 2-3 of those networking sites), including StumbleUpon over at a1-fan-fun.
    It would be great if you could participate and submit this article.
  • AndyBeard · 1 year ago
    Normally when you are the first person to stumble a site, a window pops up for you to review it.

    If that doesn't appear, but the page is showing it is thumbed up, click on the "reviews of this page" and add a review, though also best to think about what might be blocking the Stumbleupon window.
  • inspirationbit · 1 year ago
    I think this is the first time I come across someone finding holes in StumbleUpon. I'm having a big issue with StumbleUpon, that I don't know how to resolve and what causes it:
    whenever I Stumble a new page, it shows that "someone discovered" it, not me, not my nick. Does anyone know why is that?

    Also, Andy, there's a Social Media Mega Project going on that accepts submissions about 19 different social media sites (hosted by 10 different bloggers, who host 2-3 of those networking sites), including StumbleUpon over at a1-fan-fun.
    It would be great if you could participate and submit this article.
  • AndyBeard · 1 year ago
    Normally when you are the first person to stumble a site, a window pops up for you to review it.

    If that doesn't appear, but the page is showing it is thumbed up, click on the "reviews of this page" and add a review, though also best to think about what might be blocking the Stumbleupon window.
  • ny seo · 1 year ago
    i love stumbeupon but the friend limit is retarded.

    and such a popular site should not have to resort to petty tricks to get more income.

    and if they were monetizing effectively, they would not have any feature where users have to pay money.

    they should be swimming in revenue from advertisers.

    and again, the use of nofollows to links in our profile is greedy, just like del.icio.us

    reminiscent of scrubs on the court trying any trick they can think of to get a basket. lol

    your better than that StumbleUpon ! step up yo game
  • ny seo · 1 year ago
    i love stumbeupon but the friend limit is retarded.

    and such a popular site should not have to resort to petty tricks to get more income.

    and if they were monetizing effectively, they would not have any feature where users have to pay money.

    they should be swimming in revenue from advertisers.

    and again, the use of nofollows to links in our profile is greedy, just like del.icio.us

    reminiscent of scrubs on the court trying any trick they can think of to get a basket. lol

    your better than that StumbleUpon ! step up yo game
  • Tanning Freak · 1 year ago
    Some things I would like added are:

    1) Ability to see EVERYONE who has stumbled your site.

    2) Able to see your friends' fans or at least a feature where common fans wold be shown.

    3) Something like Twitter where you keep on getting alerted when your friends update their status/profile/favourite pages.

    4) Ability for everyone to actually BURY spammy stories.
  • Tanning Freak · 1 year ago
    Some things I would like added are:

    1) Ability to see EVERYONE who has stumbled your site.

    2) Able to see your friends' fans or at least a feature where common fans wold be shown.

    3) Something like Twitter where you keep on getting alerted when your friends update their status/profile/favourite pages.

    4) Ability for everyone to actually BURY spammy stories.
  • Mergen · 1 year ago
    #3 would be really good. Can't believe it's still not implemented. I tried doing it with yahoo pipes - pulling out friend IDs off your friends pages and making the feed links out of that, but I keep getting stuck. Any pipe wizards willing to give it a shot? Share it here if you do :)
  • Mergen · 1 year ago
    #3 would be really good. Can't believe it's still not implemented. I tried doing it with yahoo pipes - pulling out friend IDs off your friends pages and making the feed links out of that, but I keep getting stuck. Any pipe wizards willing to give it a shot? Share it here if you do :)
  • Mergen · 1 year ago
    Can't believe #3 still hasn't been implemented.

    I tried using yahoo pipes to pull out IDs from the friends page and make an rss feed that way, but I keep getting stuck. Any pipes wizards want to have a go? Please share here. :)
  • Mergen · 1 year ago
    Can't believe #3 still hasn't been implemented.

    I tried using yahoo pipes to pull out IDs from the friends page and make an rss feed that way, but I keep getting stuck. Any pipes wizards want to have a go? Please share here. :)
  • MERGEN · 1 year ago
    Oops, sorry about the double post.

    Solved the pipes problem - got something resembling the 'What's new' page. Try it

    StumbleUpo Friend Feed
  • AndyBeard · 1 year ago
    No worries, I will delete one of them, I was just a little too busy.

    Not sure how well this will apeear in the comments, but I just created a badge of the results.

    <script src="http://pipes.yahoo.com/js/listbadge.js">{"pipe_id":"_owCeTAw3RGS_A_oJhOy0Q","_btype":"list","pipe_params":{"textinput":"http:\/\/www.stumbleupon.com\/syndicate.php?stumbler=","urlinput2":"http:\/\/andybeard.stumbleupon.com\/friends\/all\/"},"width":"400","height":"500"}</script>
  • AndyBeard · 1 year ago
    The big negative of this version is how long it takes to load the pip each time. It would need to be cached, and probably show a name for who stumbled it.
  • MERGEN · 1 year ago
    Oops, sorry about the double post.

    Solved the pipes problem - got something resembling the 'What's new' page. Try it

    StumbleUpo Friend Feed
  • AndyBeard · 1 year ago
    No worries, I will delete one of them, I was just a little too busy.

    Not sure how well this will apeear in the comments, but I just created a badge of the results.

    <script src="http://pipes.yahoo.com/js/listbadge.js">{"pipe_id":"_owCeTAw3RGS_A_oJhOy0Q","_btype":"list","pipe_params":{"textinput":"http:\/\/www.stumbleupon.com\/syndicate.php?stumbler=","urlinput2":"http:\/\/andybeard.stumbleupon.com\/friends\/all\/"},"width":"400","height":"500"}</script>
  • AndyBeard · 1 year ago
    The big negative of this version is how long it takes to load the pip each time. It would need to be cached, and probably show a name for who stumbled it.
  • PERCE-NEIGE · 6 months ago
    Good article (I added it on Stumble ;-)

    Yes, I have some

    I'd like SU to be more open to non-English speaking people. There are big problems when you discover a site which the title contains diacritic signs (as the é, è, à, ë, ö, ô, ï , î, as we have in European languages as French by example)

    Why the SU menus are not translated, i have many French not able to speak a single English word. I'd like to invite them on SU.

    The stumble in a specific language is not well build.

    They removed the language spoken on the stumblers' profiles, so I can't know the language to use to message someone. It would be the minimum to have an automatic flag indicating from which country is the stumbler's IP.

    I'd like to select few of my tags and propose my guesses to stumble through some of them.
    I'd like to organize better my reviews for aesthetic purpose.

    I'd like to add javascript more easily in my review (widgets).

    I'd like to change the pages title to make it more explicit or beautiful, keeping the original in addition one of course.

    I noticed too a bug in the guesses counter, my conter indicate more visitors than the SU's one.

    I'd like a better stumbler repertory (to find with * for a part of the name by example) and the repertory shoud be more easy to find.

    MY STRONGEST DESIRE: I would really like to be able to stumble althrough my own stumble, both to check the quality of my blog and to keep SU as my only bookmark site and get rid of Del.ici.ous etc...

    And so many other ideas...
  • PERCE-NEIGE · 6 months ago
    My wish list go on...

    And I'd like to be able to switch between 2 different versions of my blog, one in English, one in another language.

    I'd like to have a specific place to keep the pages I didn't read well by lack of time. I know it is not the main goal of SU, but it would be a great and useful addition.

    I'd like to avoid the SU graveyard too by adding a rate with my reviews, so my best rated sites would be stumbled specifically.

    I'd like the site to have a permalink, so many good articles and pictures move at another web adress after a while...

    Some sites are old but still very good and are not limited by the time, so it would be good to not be limited to the most recent sites. To add a completely time-random stumble would be interesting.

    A flag or a map counter should be added as a SU function.

    To add pictures to the blog is easier than before but still bugged sometimes. (especially big pictures in Firefox) To place these pictures at the place I want is not easy.

    I would like to be able to do a true blog with SU based on my reviews and the webstuff I like.

    I'd like to be able to do a search with 2 keywords (ex: europ AND politics)

    The correction of the wrong topics doesn't work properly, and it seems impossible to remove some tags (by ex French Google is tagged with "sexe")
  • AndyBeard · 6 months ago
    A really thoughtful list of features and bugs that really should be looked at, thanks for your contribution
  • PERCE-NEIGE · 5 months ago
    That's irritate me right now is that the maximum amount of tags is only 5, I'd like to describe very acurately the page I send to SU and it will avoid the "graveyard" by allowing easily other users to find this page if they are make a search with one of the related topics. (I hope I'm clear because my English is not so good)

    I noticed that some people complain about the difficulty to clear SU browser history.

    I'd like to manage my SU visited page history.

    Why there is a tag for "photos" and one for "photography"?
    Every pictures should be automatically detected and tagged "images" for example.
    I like to stumble other users ' photograph or painting.

    When a site is available in many languages (in its menu by ex), it should be specific function to send the page to all the language in one move.

    I encourage every stumbler visiting this page to add a review because I hope this wish and report bugs list will have a large broadcast. Why they didn't yet?